“Poor God,” I thought. “God gave away all control over us when God gave us free will.”
It was one of my first thoughts when Daddy killed himself. I felt sorry for God and thought God helpless. I imagined God crying along with my family, grief-stricken. Everyone loved my father and thought well of him. Everyone was hurt by my Dad’s death, including God.
I foolishly worried that God would have no choice but to send my Dad to hell. From the first day, I started bargaining. I remembered rationalizing that certainly as my father’s Judge, God would have to take into consideration mental illness—even human judges did that. Didn’t they? Surely, my family and I were about pay enough of a hell-debt to get Daddy into heaven. I wasn’t the only one with this worry. One aunt said she was almost sure that Daddy had been baptized, as if that saved him from Hell—as if God would have sent him straight to hell.
That fear of my father going to hell was covered over later with feelings of hurt and anger. My husband and I were invited to a neighbor’s party. All the women chatted together for a while in the kitchen. One woman talked about her love for God and stupidly said how sorry she felt for people who kill themselves because they would never get to heaven. Such judgmental words about God flowed out of the same mouth that had just described a loving God. I wished, at the time, that I could have said my thoughts to her, but I hurt too much to speak. And I was too afraid of what I would say. My stomach ached from swallowing my words.
It took me a while to get a handle on God’s power over death since Daddy’s suicide. I started reading the Old Testament; I wanted evidence of a powerful God who could save my father. What I learned really didn’t have anything to do with the business between God and Daddy. The day after he died, an Episcopal priest told me that she believed God gave redemption even after death. She said that she felt God would heal his mind and give him time to make amends. Daddy’s impulsive actions, sins if you want to call them that, were now between him and God.
I learned more about my own relationship with God. God wanted me to always ask, to always seek, to always find courage. God was a tough old character who weathered my anger, despair, and even my lack of faith. God wanted me to be happy. But even a Higher Power couldn’t make me happy or make me live in the Now, the kingdom of heaven where God is, without my consent. That was (and is) the gift of free will. It was (and is) my choice.
“Do we really worship a God who is unable to be God when people need God the most? None of us have kept the commandments. Do we really believe God’s hands are tied by anything?”
…Rev. David Sawyer
Amy Jones said:
I had an ex-boyfriend who killed himself. I wrote a piece on my blog about this, it is very frustrating when people assume that when someone does this that it's black and white. If we aren't there in the end and God welcomes them home then the rest of us remain clueless. We can't being to understand Kingdom things and when we try we usually sound like we know nothing at all.
Karen Phillips said:
Thank you, Amy. I am sad for the loss of your ex-boyfriend.